Pragmatic enchantment : William James, psychical research, and the humanities in the American Research University, 1880-1910

View/ Open
Metadata
Show full item recordAbstract
Pragmatic Enchantment juxtaposes the histories of two intellectual movements from the fin de siècle that could not appear more different on their surfaces: pragmatism, or the philosophical approach that predicates the truth value of a belief or theory based on the success of its practical application, and psychical research, the scientific investigation of telepathy and allied phenomena. This study makes the argument that beneath the surface, psychical research was a major formative influence on pragmatism. The intertwinement of the two has been obscured because of the unlikely comparison between what is largely deemed a pseudo-science and the pristine reputation of a cornerstone of American intellectual life. In confluence, this study argues, these two intellectual movements played a contributory role in defending the state of humanistic inquiry in late-nineteenth century research universities. For William James, among the most famous of psychical researchers, I argue that his philosophy of pragmatism as it exists throughout his corpus from The Principles of Psychology to Pragmatism was rooted in his grappling with the need for personally meaningful or “live hypotheses” through the field of psychical research. First-generation pragmatists Charles Peirce, F.C.S. Schiller, and Henri Bergson were all involved in psychical research, and an examination of their writings in this arena reveals its influence on their contributions to pragmatism. At the same time, rescaling psychical research’s place in history through a networked view unveils its connection to changes in higher education, particularly its programmatic relevance to American research universities which were swiftly turning towards an emphasis on the STEM fields. The professionalization of psychical research led to the establishment of programs at institutions like the University of Pennsylvania and Stanford University. These programs created lines of scholarly communication through investigations undertaken collaboratively by both science and humanities professors. While the development of research universities would seem to support Max Weber’s popular thesis of secularization and Entzauberung (disenchantment) in the wake of late-nineteenth century scientific progress, this study argues to the contrary: psychical research propounded the very pragmatism of enchantment. It carried a humanistic raison d’etre for bringing “live hypotheses” into the investigative spirit of American research universities.
Department
Subject
Pragmatism
Psychical research
William James
University studies
Enchantment
Disenchantment
Telepathy
Demarcation problem
History of psychology
Charles Sanders Peirce
Henri Bergson
F.C.S. Schiller
Seybert Commission
Society for Psychical Research
F.W.H. Myers
Edmund Gurney
Psychology
Parapsychology
Ether
Spiritualism
Occult
Occultism
Research university
Humanities
Live questions
Live hypotheses
Elan vital
Mother wit
Randomization
Psychical research
William James
University studies
Enchantment
Disenchantment
Telepathy
Demarcation problem
History of psychology
Charles Sanders Peirce
Henri Bergson
F.C.S. Schiller
Seybert Commission
Society for Psychical Research
F.W.H. Myers
Edmund Gurney
Psychology
Parapsychology
Ether
Spiritualism
Occult
Occultism
Research university
Humanities
Live questions
Live hypotheses
Elan vital
Mother wit
Randomization
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
White Paper: Pop-Up Institute: Seeing the tree and the forest: Understanding the causes and consequences of individual and population variation in biology, medicine, and society
Solomon-Lane, Tessa K; Hofmann, Hans A (2017)The Pop-Up Institute "Seeing the Tree and the Forest: Understanding Individual and Population Variation in Biology, Medicine, and Society" brought together researchers from UT Austin’s College of Natural Sciences, College ... -
Conservation status assessment of the endangered Mexican Blindcat, Prietella phreatophila
Dugan, Laura E.; Hendrickson, Dean A.; Hernández-Espriú, Antonio; Garrett, Gary P.; Cohen, Adam E.; Wolaver, Brad; Smith, Ryan (2017-07-15)Discovery of the Mexican blindcat, Prietella phreatophila, in Texas in 2016 generated interest in the species, which had previously only been known from Mexico but is listed as a foreign endangered species in the US. ... -
Discovery of Endangered Mexican Blindcat, Prietella phreatophila, in Texas: Implications for International Groundwater Management and Evolution of the Regional Karst Aquifer Biota
Hendrickson, Dean A.; Hernández-Espriú, Antonio; Dugan, Laura; Sprouse, Peter; Dávila Paulín, José Antonio; Krejca, Jean; Gluesenkamp, Andrew; Reddell, James; Smith, Ryan; Howard, Sarah; Johnson, Jack; Garrett, Gary P.; Cohen, Adam E.; García De León, Francisco J.; Wolaver, Brad; Fenolio, Dante B. (2017-07-15)Mexican blindcat, Prietella phreatophila, described in 1954 from a cave system near the town of Múzquiz in central Coahuila state, and considered a Mexican endemic, was listed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service as a ...