NUMBER41 PEARCE-SELLARDS SERIES PALEOECOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS OFA HOLOCENE FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGE Lower Rio Grande, Cameron County, Texas elevation in m AUGUST, 1985 TEXAS MEMORIAL MUSEUM, THE UNNERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN Pearce-Sellards Series 41 PALEOECOLOGICAL IMPLICATIONS OFA HOLOCENE FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGE Lower Rio Grande, Cameron County, Texas Raymond W. Neck AUGUST, 1985 TEXAS MEMORIAL MUSEUM, THE U~IVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN Raymond W. Neck is Biologist for the Master Planning Branch, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, Austin, Texas. The Pearce-Sellards Series is an occasional, miscellaneous series of brief reports of Museum and Museum-associated field investigations and other research. All manuscripts are subjected to extramural peer review before being accepted. The series title commemorates the first two directors of Texas Memorial Museum, both now deceased : Dr. J. E. Pearce, Professor of Anthropology, and Dr. E. H. Sellards, Professor of Geology, The University of Texas at Austin. A portion of the Museum's general ope­rating funds for this fiscal year has been provided by a grant from the Institute of Museum Services, a federal agency that offers general operating support to the nation's museums. © 1985 by Texas Memorial Museum The University of Texas at Austin All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America CONTENTS Abstract .. . ...................... . ... ... ......... ..... ..... 1 Acknowledgements. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Fossil Site . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Fossil Assemblage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Aquatic Mollusks. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Miscellaneous Biota. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Plant Remains . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Age of Fossil Site ............................................ 6 Paleoenvironmental Reconstruction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Origin of Fossil Assemblage . . ........ . ......... .. . ... ...... . ... . 8 Paleogeological and Paleoclimatological Implications ..... . .......... . 11 Concluding Remark ...........................................14 References...................... , . ..... .. ........ . ..........15 LIST OF FIGURES Fig. 1. Map of lower Rio Grande, Cameron County, Texas . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Fig. 2. Localized Map of Tejon Biota site .................. ........ 3 Fig. 3. Orientation of valves of Cyrena ida relative to water movement . . .... . .... ....... . ...... ... . . ... . ... ... ....10 Fig. 4. Orientation of shells of Cyrenoida, Pyrgophorus and Physa relative to water movement. .. . . ..... . . ... .... .... .. .. .. .. 10 LIST OF TABLES Table 1. Number of organisms recorded from Tejon Local Fauna, Resaca del Rancho Viejo, Cameron Co., Texas . . .. .. .. . . .. ... .4 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I thank T. G. Littleton, H. W. Harry and T. G. Pulley for identification and verification of specimens of Cyrenoida. D. H. Riskind provided assistance in identification of recovered seeds. J. Prentice analyzed the fish scales and found them to be unidentifiable. S. Aronow provided an invaluable critique of an earlier draft of this report. Several anonymous reviewers also provided comments which improved the manuscript. ABSTRACT A Late Holocene fossil site from extreme southern Texas consists of inverte­brate remains dominated by terrestrial, freshwater and brackish water mol­lusks. Sparse plant remains were recovered. Analysis of the origin of this heterogeneous fossil biota indicates that a brackish marsh was periodically inundated by freshwater runoff. The presence of a marsh clam not known living in the area today is significant; the fossil site is reconstructed to have been a brackish marsh habitat at elevation of 3.6 meters above mean sea level. A brackish marsh at this elevation may indicate high sea levels, although exis­tence of nontidal brackish marshes are known from the lower Texas coast. Changes in river flow and seasonal distribution of local precipitation, and/or regional runoff, are postulated to explain the existence of a saline marsh in an area where this biotype is extremely rare today. INTRODUCTION The purpose of this report is to describe a fossil assemblage discovered in the Holocene alluvial plain of the Lower Rio Grande and to reconstruct paleo­environmental conditions. Additionally, a hypothesis as to the causal factors resulting in the fossil assemblage is postulated. The paleogeological and paleo­climatological implications of the fossil assemblage are also discussed. Until recent human activities confined the regularly-flooding lower Rio Grande, the Lower Rio Grande "Valley" (actually an alluvial plain) of Texas was very active in hydrogeological terms. The Rio Grande has been an active­ly meandering stream throughout the Holocene into contemporary time. Several subdeltas were deposited and later partially eroded (LeBlanc 1958). Local course changes left several abandoned channels (Pryor et al. 1976), known by the Spanish term resacas. Such an active hydrogeological environ­ment undoubtedly was accompanied by dynamic biological systems which responded to changing physical conditions. Few data exist concerning the biological dynamics of the lower Rio Grande. Richards (1939) and Trow­bridge ( 1932:226) reported the existence of Pleistocene fossil molluscan strata, but discussed regional geological phenomena rather than local paleoenviron­ments. FOSSIL SITE A fossil fauna was located in sediments of the now intermittent Resaca del Rancho Viejo, Cameron County, approximately 9.5 kilometers north of Brownsville (fig. 1 and 2). The fossiliferous layer (6 mm in thickness), con­sisting of mixed clay and silt, forms the surface deposit of the sloping bank above the lowest portion of the resaca. Below the stratum studied is a 30 mm layer which contains some fossil remains, but which was not intensively sam­pled because of the lack of the marsh clam. The fossiliferous layer was ob­served over a distance of 840 meters along the length of Resaca del Rancho Viejo. Width of the sediment has been verified for a width of 33 meters on both sides of the present water channel. The present environment is slightly brackish as expressed by the presence of halophytes, fiddler crabs (Uca) and slight salt deposition during drought periods. Fig. l. Map of lower Rio Grande, Cameron County, Texas. Asterisk marks fossil locality . 0 elevation in m Fig. 2. Localized map of Tejon Biota site. FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGE Following an initial visual survey of the fossiliferous strata, I sampled the biota by two methods. I removed circular portions (10 em in diameter, located at random) of the layer containing the fossils until approximately 750 cc of material had been gathered. This material yielded the species which are dis­cussed immediately below. Additionally, an ad libitum sampling of marsh clam shells was accomplished by recording horizontal and vertical orientation of the valves; the resultant data are discussed below under "Origin of Faunal Assemblage." Sediment samples were analyzed by soaking the sediments in water fol­lowed by screening through soil sieves (No. 8, No. 16 and No. 30-U.S. Stan­dard Sieve Series). Samples were air dried and hand-picked. The most abun­dantly recovered specimens were shells of two species of freshwater gastro­pods and one species of marsh clam. Low numbers of arthropods, terrestrial gastropods and plant remains were also recovered. Numbers following scien­tific names in the following paragraphs are counts from the extracted sample; ad libitum sampling of Cyrenoida added additional specimens of this species (See Table 1.). The biota discussed below is called the Tejon Biota after the adjacent El Tejon Road. (Tejon means "badger" in Spanish; this meaning has no application to the use of the word here.) Table l. Number of organisms recorded from Tejon Local Fauna, Resaca del Rancho Viejo, Cameron Co., Texas. Pyrgophorus coronatus 4034 Helicioo orbiculate 2 Physa virgata 339 Gastrocopta riograndensis 1 Succinea luteola 2 Glyphyalinia umbilicata 1 Thysanophora horni 1 Cyrenoida floridana 3 AQUATIC MOLLUSKS Pyrgophorus coronatus (Pfeiffer)-4034. This small hydrobiid snail is found in ponds and slow-moving waters from theWest Indies and Mexico northward into Texas as far north as the Guadalupe River (Fullington 1979 :46). Carnes (1974) reported deposited specimens in "peaty sediments of the back lagoon marsh" in Quintana Roo, Mexico. Majors (1964) noted numerous empty shells in drift piles but did find living specimens on stalks of "grasslike plants" in a drainage ditch near Harlingen, approximately 32 kilometers northwest of the Tejon Biota site. Living populations appear to be scarce in the area today. Specimens vary in a continuum from very spinose to the smooth form (texana phenotype of Pilsbry). Increased spination of gastropod shells has been asso­ciated with increased alkalinity/salinity (Goodrich 1934; Real1973) or "bad" conditions (Boycott 1929). Fullington (1979:47) suggested a tendency for spinose shells of P. coronatus to be found in relatively fast water current areas, while smooth shells are generally found in quiet backwaters; however, this relationship has yet to be rigorously examined. Most P. coronatus shells from this sample exhibit at least a few spines. Shell height of recovered P. coronatus varies from 1.4 to 4.9 mm; shells do not exhibit abrasion marks. This species is by far the most abundant species represented in the recovered sample. Physella virgata Gould-339. The pond snail occurs over much of the southern United States and northern Mexico. Shell morphology is quite varia­ble as an ecogenetic response to variable water conditions, but all Texas popu­lations have been placed in a single taxon (Fullington 1979:164). While P. virgata can withstand waters of differing quality, local populations are found in non-moving to slow-current waters; stagnant water is tolerated. Shells re­covered tend to be small (height of largest specimen-9.7mm), but modern P virgata shells from Cameron County tend to be equally small. This species was the second most common species recovered in the sample. Cyrenoida floridana Dall-3. The Florida marsh clam is known from salt marshes of the Atlantic and Gulf coasts of the United States. No records of living C. floridana are known from Texas (Pulley, pers. comm.). Parker (1960) did not list C. floridana from his "low-salinity marsh assemblage." Texas re­cords are restricted to the Holocene of Cameron Co. (Neck & Herber 1981); Herber (1981: 596) reported C. floridana from Late Holocene deposits dated at 3160 t 50 B.P. The largest specimen found in the sample of the Tejon Bio­ta measures 18.5 mm in length and 16.7 mm in height, as compared to 13.5 mm and 12.5 mm, respectively, for the largest Florida specimen reported by Dall (1896). Remnants of periostracum have persisted where the valve was in contact with the clay matrix. While most valves were single and parallel to the substrate, :everal articulated valve pairs in natural position (perpendicular to substrate) were collected. These latter shells have apparently remained in situ since time of death. M1SCELLANEOUS BIOTA Several other animal species were recovered from the sediment samples. Limit­ed numbers (given in parentheses) of the following terrestrial gastropods were observed: Helicina orbiculata (2), Gastrocopta riograndensis (1), Succinea luteota (2), Glyphyalinia umbilicata (1), and Thysanophora horni (1). Also recovered were remains of a water scavenger beetle (Hydrophilus triangularis), fiddler crab (Uca sp.), and non-diagnostic fish scales. All identifiable species represented occur in the close vicinity of the site today. PLANT REMAINS Various plant remains were recovered. Present were halves of the stony exo­carp of Celtis laevigata Willd., the Texas sugarberry or hackberry, which is common in woodlands flanking the Rio Grande and water-filled resacas. Also present were seeds of smartweed, Polygonum sp., a wetland species typical of len tic waters. AGE OF FOSSIL SITE While considerable geological reconnaissance has been reported on the Rio Grande deltaic plain (Trowbridge 1923, 1932; LeBlanc 1958; LeBlanc & Hodgson 1959; Curray 1960; Brown et al. 1980), very few absolute dates associated with specific sediments have been published. Following the last glacial maximum (ca. 18,000 B.P.), rising sea levels resulted in inundation of the Wisconsinan valley of the Rio Grande, forming a large estuarine area in what is now eastern Cameron County. This Late Wisconsin/Early Holocene bay was much larger than the present-day Laguna Madre, which has been re­duced by sedimentation and development of the barrier island system. Sedi­mentation became more rapid during the period 7000 to 5000 B.P., as sea level began to approach present-day sea level. In southern Texas, this rapid rise in sea level was accompanied by river valley submergence and filling, in addition to the initial development of an offshore barrier island system by 4500 B.P. (Behrens 1974; Suhm et al. 1977; Russell & Suhm 1980). Lohse (1962:55) placed Resaca del Rancho Viejo within the Del Tigre subdelta of the Middle Holocene~ The Del Tigre subdelta was a southern extension of the river which followed the more northern Los Cuates subdelta of the Early Holocene. A slight northward shift of the lower­most Rio Grande during the Late Holocene initiated formation of the current Boca Chica subdelta. Pryor et al. (1976) reported carbon-14 dates for two distributary systems of the Holocene Rio Grande: Resaca dela Gringa (5000 B.P.) and a "Southern system" (7000 B.P. ). Resaca del Rancho Viejo occurs south of these two sys­ tems and is merely labeled (along with Resaca de la Palma) as "youngest" Rio Grande by Pryor et al. (1976). The fossil layer from Resaca del Rancho Viejo is likely to be no older than 3000 B.P. (Neck & Herber 1981 ). This dating is made relative to known ages of older resaca systems (Pryor, et al. 1976; Herber 1981). PALEOENVIRONMENTAL RECONSTRUCTION The above reported fossil assemblage is basically a freshwater biota with rep­resentatives from brackish and terrestrial habitats. The freshwater species are indicative of a freshwater pool, or sl >w-moving stream, with shallow water and emergent vegetation. The brackish water component, i.e., Cyrenoida, in­dicates brackish marsh. Thorn woodland at the time of deposition would be similar to present-day species composition, although more mesic-adapted spe­cies could have been relatively more abundant. Presence of C. floridana indicates a well-developed salt marsh. The Florida marsh clam has long been known from intertidal marshes of Florida and Georgia where it has been found in "brackish, or even tolerably salt water, indifferently" (Dall 1896). Morrison (1954) reported living populations to­ward the freshwater portion of intertidal marshes in Chesapeake Bay and Delaware. Rehder (1954) reported C. floridana as characteristic of "brackish water estuaries" of the Caribbean Province (which includes the southern Texas area), but gave no specific localities. Abbott (1974:466) reports C. floridana "in brackish to rather fresh water." More recently, C. floridana has been found living in Spartina/Distichlis salt marshes associated with Delaware Bay (Leathem, et al. 1976) where it is well adapted to live in intertidal marsh areas (Kat 1978). Reports of C. floridana from the Gulf of Mexico are sparse; the species has not been reported from Mississippi (Moore 1961 ), but has been found in Louisiana salt marshes (Harold Harry, pers. comm. ). Absence of C. floridana from Texas localities with Spartina/Distichlis salt marshes is not presently understood, but may be related to periodic droughts which reduce inflow of freshwater. Delaware salt marsh populations were densest in the Distichlis spicata zone (Leathem et al. 1976 ); areas of denser Cyrenoida populations were asso­ciated with sediments containing increased levels of volatiles (vegetation re­mains) and water content. This may indicate dependence on sediment-trapped water during low tidal periods and utilization for food of detritus originating from buried organic matter. Increased plant density in areas of Cyrenoida occurrence led Leathem et al. (1976) to speculate that stem density may ameliorate temperature and light variation as reported by Kraueter and Wolf (1974). In Florida, C. floridana is the characteristic bivalve of upper and high marsh zones (Subramanyan et al. 1976). Indication that the Tejon Biota site was a high marsh area is given by the absence of typical salt marsh mollusks, e.g. Truncatella, Polymeseda and Melampus. ORIGIN OF FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGE 1) This assemblage could represent a freshwater biota which was devastated by an influx of salt water. Salt water could have entered a freshwater system as a hurricane surge tide (Carr 1967; Geiser I944; Schlesselman 1945) which traveled up Resaca del Rancho Viejo from the Gulf of Mexico. The distance along the course of Resaca del Rancho Viejo to the vicinity of the Laguna Madre of Tejon time would be greater than that of today. The last major transgression of early Holocene delta sediments occurred during the period 3400 to 1900 B.P. (Brown et al. 1980:20-22). Biological effects of surge tides associated with hurricanes (Hubbs 1962; Chabreck & Palmisano 1973; Egler 1952; Valentine 1978) includes mortality offreshwater marsh vegetation and transport of marine organisms into freshwater habitats. Sedill,lent transport by modern hurricanes in the Rio Grande area has been discussed by Morton and Pieper (1975). Price and Kornicker (1961) discussed hurricane flotsam found buried in mainland clay dunes and barrier island sand dunes of Cameron County. No shell was discovered, however; the majority of flotsam consisted of asphalt lumps, coral fragments, tropical seeds, pumice and other similar materials more bouyant than shell fragments. However, Kat (1978:103) reported that individuals of C. floridana exhibit two techniques by which flotation occurs. Closed valve surfaces which dry during low tidal periods permit individuals to float at the surface until capillary flow of water over the shell breaks the surface tension. C. floridana may also take air into the mantle cavity during shell gaping. Feeding may occur during surface floating periods. Some con­trol may be exerted over float period length as air bubbles may be expelled at will. Death of over 4,000 P. coronatus is indicative of an alteration of water condition. Desiccation/heating of a pool due to extreme drought (Lowry 1959) is possible, but would not explain the existence of C. floridana in a freshwater habitat. Cold shock deaths due to unusually severe periodically­occurring (Haddock 1963; Orton eta!. 1967) freezes have been reported for Laguna Madre and similar bay areas along the south Texas coast (Gunter & Hildebrand 1951; Moore 1976). However, all of the aquatic mollusks occur farther north than the study locality. While one would expect individuals of such species to withstand even record extreme cold events of the Lower Rio Grande, existence of locally adapted cold-intolerant populations cannot be ruled out. The most likely cause of death of the freshwater snails will be dis­cussed after consideration of the second alternative. 2) Alternatively, a brackish biota could have been devastated by a fresh­water/sediment influx following torrential rains (Hubbs 1962; Zimmerman & Chaney 1969; Russell & Wood 1976). Flood debris found along high water levels in creeks and rivers often contains much shell materials as well as living individuals. Hurricane Beulah in 1967 brought torrential rains which caused extensjve flooding and ponding (Crozier et al. 1968; Baker 1971 ). Orientation of in situ fossil shells can provide clues as to the method of deposition and transport of the shells to their fossilized resting spot. Water is less likely to move a shell from a convex-up position than from a concave-up position (Johnson 195 7), because the current can reach under and lift the periphery of a concave-up shell. Orientation of C. floridana shells was mea­sured at the sediment surface by recording shell position as convex side "up" or "down," in addition to noting the compass direction of the umbo. Of 19 single valves over 12 mm length, 18 were convex-up. Such a preponderance of convex-up over concave-up indicates underwater movement as the former position is the more stable position. Shells in a current will tend to rotate to expose a symmetrical cross-sec­tion to the current (Johnson 1957). Depending upon left-right valve asym­metry and swash zone dynamics, some species exhibit a surplus of either left or right valves (Martin-Kay 1951; Lever 1958). However, no significant ine­quality (ll left; 8 right valves) was detected for C. floridana. A significant hydrological asymmetry apparently exists between right and left valves of C. floridana, since umbo orientation of left valves (X = 201.0°, n = 10) differs significantly (t